March 2012
| Date | Time | Home Team | Away Team | Venue |
| 11 SUN | 3:00PM EDT | FC Dallas | New York | FC Dallas Stadium |
| 17 SAT | 9:00PM EDT | Real Salt Lake | New York | Rio Tinto Stadium |
| 25 SUN | 4:00PM EDT | New York | Colorado | Red Bull Arena |
| 31 SAT | 4:00PM EDT | New York | Montreal | Red Bull Arena |
April 2012
| Date | Time | Home Team | Away Team | Venue |
| 07 SAT | 3:00PM EDT | Columbus | New York | Crew Stadium |
| 14 SAT | 7:00PM EDT | New York | San Jose | Red Bull Arena |
| 22 SUN | 6:00PM EDT | D.C. United | New York | RFK Stadium |
| 28 SAT | 3:30PM EDT | New York | New England | Red Bull Arena |
May 2012
| Date | Time | Home Team | Away Team | Venue |
| 05 SAT | 8:00PM EDT | Los Angeles | New York | Home Depot Center |
| 09 WED | 7:00PM EDT | New York | Houston | Red Bull Arena |
| 13 SUN | 1:30PM EDT | Philadelphia | New York | PPL Park |
| 19 SAT | 7:30PM EDT | Montreal | New York | Stade Saputo |
| 23 WED | TBD | New York | Chivas USA | Red Bull Arena |
June 2012
| Date | Time | Home Team | Away Team | Venue |
| 17 SUN | 5:00PM EDT | Chicago | New York | Toyota Park |
| 20 WED | 11:00PM EDT | Vancouver | New York | Whitecaps Waterfront Stadium |
| 24 SUN | 7:00PM EDT | New York | D.C. United | Red Bull Arena |
| 30 SAT | 7:00PM EDT | Toronto FC | New York | BMO Field |
July 2012
| Date | Time | Home Team | Away Team | Venue |
| 08 SUN | 7:00PM EDT | New England | New York | Gillette Stadium |
| 15 SUN | 4:00PM EDT | New York | Seattle | Red Bull Arena |
| 18 WED | 1:00PM EDT | New York | Chicago | Red Bull Arena |
| 21 SAT | 2:30PM EDT | New York | Philadelphia | Red Bull Arena |
| 28 SAT | 7:00PM EDT | Montreal | New York | Stade Saputo |
August 2012
| Date | Time | Home Team | Away Team | Venue |
| 03 FRI | 8:00PM EDT | Houston | New York | BBVA Compass Stadium |
| 10 FRI | 8:00PM EDT | New York | Houston | Red Bull Arena |
| 19 SUN | 7:00PM EDT | New York | Portland | Red Bull Arena |
| 26 SUN | 9:00PM EDT | Sporting KC | New York | LIVESTRONG Sporting Park |
| 29 WED | 8:00PM EDT | D.C. United | New York | RFK Stadium |
September 2012
| Date | Time | Home Team | Away Team | Venue |
| 15 SAT | 7:00PM EDT | New York | Columbus | Red Bull Arena |
| 19 WED | 7:00PM EDT | New York | Sporting KC | Red Bull Arena |
| 22 SAT | 7:30PM EDT | New England | New York | Gillette Stadium |
| 29 SAT | 7:00PM EDT | New York | Toronto FC | Red Bull Arena |
October 2012
| Date | Time | Home Team | Away Team | Venue |
| 06 WED | 3:30PM EDT | New York | Chicago | Red Bull Arena |
| 20 SAT | 7:00PM EDT | New York | Sporting KC | Red Bull Arena |
| 27 SAT | 1:30PM EDT | Piladelphia | New York | PPL Park |